Skip to content

Qualified, adverse or disclaimer: reading the auditor's opinion

Pradeep Vanga · last checked

Under Companies Act 2013, section 143; ICAI SA 700 (Revised) and SA 705 (Revised)

Short answer

Every audited company's accounts come with an auditor's opinion. A clean (unmodified) one says they are true and fair; qualified, true and fair except for a specific material problem; adverse, not true and fair; a disclaimer, that the auditor could not form an opinion.

An audit ends in one sentence

Imagine you hire a surveyor before buying a flat. They inspect it and give you a one-line verdict. “Sound.” Or “Sound, except the balcony slab, which needs work.” Or “Not sound.” Or “I could not get into half the rooms, so I cannot tell you.” Everything else in their report explains that line.

A company’s auditor does the same for its accounts. Every company must have one, and the audit ends in an opinion: whether the accounts give a true and fair view of the company’s position and results. That opinion is the first thing in the auditor’s report, under a heading that tells you at once which kind it is.

The rules for how the opinion is formed and worded are the Standards on Auditing (SAs) issued by the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI). Two of them matter here: SA 700 (Revised), which covers the clean opinion and the shape of every report, and SA 705 (Revised), which covers the three ways an opinion can be modified. The Companies Act 2013 requires every company to appoint an auditor (section 139) and makes auditors follow these standards: “Every auditor shall comply with the auditing standards” (section 143(9)).

Four opinions, and the one sentence that tells them apart

The opinion section’s heading is the fastest read in the whole annual report. SA 705 requires the auditor to use the heading “Qualified Opinion”, “Adverse Opinion” or “Disclaimer of Opinion” when the opinion is modified; a clean report says simply “Opinion”.

Heading What the auditor is saying The phrase to look for
Opinion (unmodified) The accounts are true and fair “give a true and fair view”
Qualified Opinion True and fair, except for one or more specific matters “except for the effects” or “except for the possible effects”
Adverse Opinion The accounts are not true and fair “do not give a true and fair view”
Disclaimer of Opinion The auditor gives no opinion at all “do not express an opinion”

The unmodified opinion is the normal case. Under SA 700 (Revised), paragraph 16, the auditor gives it “when the auditor concludes that the financial statements are prepared, in all material respects, in accordance with the applicable financial reporting framework”. It does not mean the company is healthy, honest or a good bet. It means the accounts describe the company fairly, whatever they describe.

The other three are the modified opinions. SA 705 (Revised) establishes “three types of modified opinions, namely, a qualified opinion, an adverse opinion, and a disclaimer of opinion”.

Two questions decide which modified opinion you get

An auditor modifies the opinion in one of two situations (SA 705, paragraph 6):

  1. The auditor has the evidence, and it shows the accounts are materially misstated: something is wrong, and it is big enough to matter to a reader.
  2. The auditor could not get enough evidence to conclude that the accounts are free from material misstatement. SA 705’s examples include records that were destroyed and management refusing the auditor access.

The second question is how far the problem spreads: is it pervasive? SA 705 defines pervasive effects as those that, in the auditor’s judgement, are not confined to specific items of the accounts; or, if confined, are or could be a substantial proportion of them; or, for disclosures, are “fundamental to users’ understanding of the financial statements”.

Put the two together and you get SA 705’s own table:

Material but not pervasive Material and pervasive
Accounts are materially misstated Qualified opinion Adverse opinion
Auditor could not get enough evidence Qualified opinion Disclaimer of opinion

So a qualified opinion has two flavours, and the wording tells you which. “Except for the effects of” means the auditor found a misstatement. “Except for the possible effects of” means the auditor could not get the evidence to find out (SA 705, paragraph 17).

An adverse opinion is the auditor saying the accounts are wrong across the board. A disclaimer is the auditor saying they cannot tell. SA 705 also allows a disclaimer in “extremely rare circumstances involving multiple uncertainties”, where the auditor has evidence on each one but cannot form an opinion because of how they might interact (paragraph 10).

Read the basis paragraph before anything else

The heading tells you there is a problem. The section directly after it tells you what the problem is. SA 705 (paragraph 20) renames “Basis for Opinion” to “Basis for Qualified Opinion”, “Basis for Adverse Opinion” or “Basis for Disclaimer of Opinion”, and requires it to describe the matter.

What that section must contain is set out in SA 705, paragraphs 21 to 24:

  • If the misstatement relates to specific amounts, a description and quantification of its financial effect, unless that is impracticable, in which case the auditor must say so.
  • If it relates to narrative disclosures, an explanation of how they are misstated.
  • If required information was left out, the nature of what is missing, and, where practicable and lawful, the omitted disclosure itself.
  • If the auditor could not get evidence, the reasons why.

Read it for three things: the amount (and how it compares with profit or net worth), whether the matter is a one-off or recurring, and whether it points to a note in the accounts where management gives its side. Then open that note.

How a reader should treat each opinion

Unmodified. Proceed to the numbers, but keep reading the report. A clean opinion can still carry an emphasis of matter paragraph, a material uncertainty about going concern, or a key audit matters section. Each is explained in its own guide: emphasis of matter and key audit matters.

Qualified. The auditor has drawn a boundary around one problem. The rest of the accounts can be read, but any figure touched by the qualified matter cannot be taken at face value. Adjust for it yourself where the basis section quantifies it. A qualification about evidence the auditor could not get (“possible effects”) is an unknown, not a known loss; treat it as a question to put to the company.

Adverse. The accounts, as filed, do not describe the company fairly. Do not build a credit, investment or pricing decision on them.

Disclaimer. There is no audited view of the company for that year. The filed statements are management’s numbers with no auditor standing behind them.

For any modified opinion, look at the years either side. A qualification that appears once and is cleared the next year reads very differently from one that repeats, or from a qualified opinion that becomes adverse.

The Companies Act adds its own questions

The auditor’s report on an Indian company does more than SA 700 requires. Section 143(3) of the Companies Act 2013 lists matters the report “shall also state”, including:

  • whether the auditor obtained all the information and explanations needed, and if not, the details and their effect on the financial statements (clause (a));
  • whether proper books of account have been kept (clause (b));
  • whether the statements comply with the accounting standards (clause (e));
  • “the observations or comments of the auditors on financial transactions or matters which have any adverse effect on the functioning of the company” (clause (f));
  • whether any director is disqualified under section 164(2) (clause (g));
  • “any qualification, reservation or adverse remark relating to the maintenance of accounts and other matters connected therewith” (clause (h));
  • whether the company has adequate internal financial controls with reference to financial statements, and whether they operate effectively (clause (i)).

These appear under a heading such as “Report on Other Legal and Regulatory Requirements”, after the opinion. Section 143(4) adds that where any of these matters is “answered in the negative or with a qualification, the report shall state the reasons therefor”. So a report can carry a clean opinion on the accounts and still say something negative further down. Read the whole section.

Clause (i) produces a separate report on internal financial controls, usually an annexure with its own opinion. It is a different opinion from the one on the accounts, and the two can differ. The auditor’s checklist under the Companies (Auditor’s Report) Order, 2020 (CARO) is another annexure; see CARO 2020.

The opinion is filed with the accounts on AOC-4

The auditor’s report travels with the accounts. Section 134(7) requires every signed financial statement to be issued with “the auditor’s report”, and section 137 requires a copy of the financial statements, “along with all the documents which are required to be or attached to such financial statements”, to be filed with the registrar within thirty days of the annual general meeting. That filing is AOC-4.

In the Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA) View Public Documents listings, these sit in the “Annual Returns and Balance Sheet eForms” category. For filings on MCA’s V3 portal, the listings also show an extract of the auditor’s report, labelled “EAUDITOR Standalone” or “EAUDITOR Consolidated”. You can see a company’s filings, including these, on its page on Entiva.

A group files two sets of accounts, standalone and consolidated, each with its own auditor’s report. The opinions can differ, so read both.

What else to check once you know the opinion

  • The board must answer it. The Board’s report must include “explanations or comments by the Board on every qualification, reservation or adverse remark or disclaimer made by the auditor in his report” (section 134(3)(f)). Read the auditor’s words next to the board’s reply. A reply that only repeats the company’s position is common; one that promises a fix gives you something to check next year.
  • It is read out to shareholders. Under section 145, the auditor’s qualifications, observations or comments on matters with an adverse effect on the company “shall be read before the company in general meeting and shall be open to inspection by any member of the company”.
  • No key audit matters after a disclaimer. When the auditor disclaims an opinion, the report must not include a Key Audit Matters section, unless law or regulation requires one (SA 705, paragraph 29). A listed company’s report with no key audit matters is worth a second look for that reason.
  • Going concern can lead to different opinions. If the company uses the going concern basis and the auditor thinks that is inappropriate, the opinion is adverse (SA 570 (Revised), paragraph 21). If there is a material uncertainty that is properly disclosed, the opinion stays unmodified with a separate section; if it is not properly disclosed, the opinion is qualified or adverse (paragraphs 22 and 23).
  • A key audit matter is not a qualification. SA 701 forbids the auditor from putting a matter that requires a modified opinion into the Key Audit Matters section instead (paragraph 12). The reverse misreading is common: a long list of key audit matters does not mean the opinion is modified.
  • Listed companies say it to the exchange as well. A listed company files its annual audited results with either a “statement on impact of audit qualifications” (when the audit report carries a modified opinion) or a declaration (when it is unmodified), under regulation 33(3)(d) of the listing regulations of the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) (SEBI FAQ, question 22).
  • An auditor leaving. A resignation is filed by the auditor on ADT-3. Read it alongside the last opinion that auditor signed.

Worked example: JSW Steel’s qualified opinion for 2024-25

JSW Steel Limited’s standalone financial statements for the year ended 31 March 2025 were audited by S R B C & CO LLP, whose report is dated 23 May 2025 (JSW Steel Integrated Report 2024-25, standalone financial statements, page 422 onwards).

The heading. The opinion section is headed “Qualified Opinion”. That alone tells you the report is not clean.

The wording. The opinion reads that, “except for the possible effects of the matter described in the ‘Basis for Qualified Opinion’ section of our report”, the statements give a true and fair view. “Possible effects” places it in the second row of the SA 705 table: the auditor could not get the evidence to judge the matter, rather than finding a misstatement.

The basis. The “Basis for Qualified Opinion” section points to note 56(b). It says the company is evaluating possible legal remedies after the Supreme Court’s rejection of its resolution plan for acquiring Bhushan Power and Steel Limited, and that the company believes there is no adverse material impact on the standalone statements. The auditor writes that, pending the outcome of those remedies and of regulatory actions, “we are unable to assess the possible consequential effects thereof on these standalone financial statements”.

How to read it. The auditor is not saying JSW Steel’s accounts are wrong. It is saying one matter could not be assessed when the report was signed, and it is ring-fenced from the rest of the opinion. A reader should open note 56(b), read the company’s position, and then look at what happened next: later results, the next year’s auditor’s report, and any court outcome. Everything above is as stated in the report signed on 23 May 2025; the court proceedings continued after that date, and this page does not follow them.

Other parts of the same report. The report also has a Key Audit Matters section, which begins “In addition to the matter described in the ‘Basis for Qualified Opinion’ section”. That is the cross-reference SA 701 requires (paragraph 15). And the separate report on internal financial controls under section 143(3)(i), in Annexure 2, is unmodified: “In our opinion, the Company has, in all material respects, adequate internal financial controls with reference to standalone financial statements”. One report, two opinions, two different answers. That is normal, and it is why the whole report is worth reading.

The detail, for practitioners

Standards and dates. SA 700 (Revised), SA 705 (Revised) and SA 706 (Revised) were issued in May 2016 and are effective for audits of financial statements for periods beginning on or after 1 April 2018, per the ICAI texts linked above. Under section 143(10), standards specified by ICAI are deemed to be the auditing standards until the Central Government notifies standards; section 143(9) requires compliance.

SA 705 (Revised), the requirements in order.

  • Paragraph 6: modify when the statements as a whole are not free from material misstatement, or when sufficient appropriate evidence cannot be obtained.
  • Paragraph 7: qualified opinion where misstatements are material but not pervasive, or where possible effects of undetected misstatements could be material but not pervasive.
  • Paragraph 8: adverse opinion where misstatements are both material and pervasive.
  • Paragraphs 9 and 10: disclaimer where possible effects could be both material and pervasive, or, in extremely rare cases, multiple uncertainties.
  • Paragraphs 11 to 14: a management-imposed scope limitation after acceptance. The auditor asks management to lift it; if refused, communicates with those charged with governance and tries alternative procedures; if the possible effects are material and pervasive, withdraws where practicable and possible under law, otherwise disclaims.
  • Paragraph 15: an adverse opinion or disclaimer on the statements as a whole cannot sit alongside an unmodified opinion on a single statement or element under the same framework.
  • Paragraph 19(c): a disclaimer amends the statement that the statements “have been audited” to say the auditor “was engaged to audit” them.
  • Paragraph 25: for a qualified or adverse opinion, the sufficiency statement in the basis section refers to a “qualified” or “adverse” opinion; paragraph 26 removes it altogether for a disclaimer.
  • Paragraph 27: even with an adverse opinion or disclaimer, the basis section must describe any other matters that would have required modification.
  • Paragraph 28: on a disclaimer, the auditor’s responsibilities section is cut down to the statements listed there.
  • Paragraph 29: no Key Audit Matters section, and no Other Information section under SA 720 (Revised), on a disclaimer, unless law or regulation requires them.

Section 143 of the Companies Act 2013. Sub-section (2) frames the report to members on whether the accounts give a true and fair view. Sub-section (3) lists the additional statements, clauses (a) to (j); clause (i) was amended by Act 1 of 2018 to read “internal financial controls with reference to financial statements” with effect from 9 February 2018. Sub-section (4) requires reasons for any negative or qualified answer. Sub-section (11) is the power under which the Central Government issues the auditor’s report order (CARO). Fraud reporting is sub-section (12), with penalties in sub-section (15).

Board’s reply. Section 134(3)(f) requires the Board’s report to explain or comment on every qualification, reservation, adverse remark or disclaimer by the auditor (and by the company secretary in the secretarial audit report). For a One Person Company, section 134(4) reduces the Board’s report to those explanations.

Listed entities. Regulation 33(3)(d) of the SEBI (Listing Obligations and Disclosure Requirements) Regulations, 2015 requires audited standalone annual results within sixty days of the year end, with the audit report and either the Statement on Impact of Audit Qualifications (modified opinion) or a declaration (unmodified opinion). Per SEBI’s FAQ, separate statements are filed for standalone and consolidated results where both are modified, and a common declaration may be filed where both are unmodified.

Sources

Checked on 17 November 2026. Laws, fees and due dates change, so confirm the current text before you rely on one. This is a guide, not legal advice.

  1. SA 700 (Revised): Forming an Opinion and Reporting on Financial Statements, ICAI
  2. SA 705 (Revised): Modifications to the Opinion in the Independent Auditor's Report, ICAI
  3. SA 701: Communicating Key Audit Matters in the Independent Auditor's Report, ICAI
  4. SA 570 (Revised): Going Concern, ICAI
  5. Companies Act 2013 (as amended), sections 134, 137, 139, 143 and 145 (India Code PDF, archived copy), India Code
  6. FAQs on the SEBI (Listing Obligations and Disclosure Requirements) Regulations, 2015 (April 2025), question 22, SEBI
  7. JSW Steel Limited, Integrated Report 2024-25: standalone financial statements and independent auditor's report, JSW Steel Limited

See it on a real company

Search the register free to see any company’s status. Then order its filings to read the forms themselves.