CARO 2020: the auditor's checklist, and the clauses to read first
Short answer
CARO 2020 is a fixed list of questions a company's auditor must answer in an annexure to the audit report: has the company defaulted on loans, paid its taxes and provident fund, suffered fraud, made cash losses or lost an auditor? It covers most companies from 2021-22 audits; banks, insurers, small companies and a few others are exempt.
A checklist the auditor has to answer out loud
An audit report is mostly about one question: do these accounts give a true and fair view? The answer is an opinion, and an auditor can give a clean opinion while noticing things a lender or supplier would very much want to know.
CARO closes that gap. It is a fixed list of questions, set by the government, that the auditor must answer one by one. Think of a vehicle fitness certificate: the inspector does not just say “roadworthy”, but ticks brakes, lights and tyres, and writes down any that failed. CARO does the same for a company’s loans, dues, assets and conduct.
Its full name is the Companies (Auditor’s Report) Order, 2020. The Central Government made it on 25 February 2020 (S.O. 849(E)) under section 143(11) of the Companies Act 2013, which lets it direct, after consulting the National Financial Reporting Authority, that the auditor’s report “shall also include a statement on such matters as may be specified”. It replaced CARO 2016. The text quoted on this page is the Order as reproduced in Appendix I of the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI) Guidance Note on CARO 2020, checked against the Ministry’s text of the Order as published by the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India.
The difference from the main opinion is the useful part. Under section 143(1) the auditor inquires into some matters but reports only if there is something to say; ICAI’s guidance note points out that CARO, by contrast, “requires a statement on each of the matters specified therein”. Silence is not an option, so a reader gets an answer even when the answer is “no problem”.
Most companies are covered, with five exceptions
Paragraph 1(2) of the Order applies it “to every company including a foreign company”, except:
- a banking company;
- an insurance company;
- a company licensed under section 8 (not-for-profit companies);
- a one person company, and a small company as defined in section 2(85) of the Act;
- a private limited company that is not a subsidiary or holding company of a public company, and that meets all three tests: paid up capital and reserves and surplus “not more than one crore rupees” on the balance sheet date; total borrowings from any bank or financial institution not “exceeding one crore rupees” at any point in the year; and total revenue, including from discontinuing operations, not “exceeding ten crore rupees” for the year.
Two more limits:
- Consolidated accounts are out, with one exception. The proviso to paragraph 2 says the Order does not apply to the auditor’s report on consolidated financial statements “except clause (xxi) of paragraph 3”. A group’s consolidated report therefore carries only that one CARO answer.
- When it started. As made, it applied to financial years beginning on or after 1 April 2019. Two amending orders, of 24 March 2020 and 17 December 2020, deferred it by a year each, so it applies to financial years beginning on or after 1 April 2021: audits of 2021-22 onwards.
So when a CARO annexure is missing, the first question is whether the company is exempt. A bank, a section 8 company or a small company will not have one.
The clauses to read first
Paragraph 3 has 21 clauses, (i) to (xxi). For someone deciding whether to lend to, supply, or invest in a company, these are the ones that carry the weight. The clause numbers below are the Order’s own.
| Clause | What the auditor must say | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| 3(ix)(a) | Whether the company “has defaulted in repayment of loans or other borrowings or in the payment of interest thereon to any lender”, with the lender, amount and days of delay in a set table | The plainest statement of credit distress anywhere in the accounts |
| 3(ix)(b) | Whether the company “is a declared wilful defaulter by any bank or financial institution or other lender” | A lender has formally classed it as able but unwilling to pay |
| 3(ix)(c) and (d) | Whether term loans were used for their purpose, and whether short-term funds were used for long-term purposes | Diversion of borrowed money, and a stretched balance sheet |
| 3(vii)(a) | Whether undisputed statutory dues (goods and services tax (GST), provident fund, employees’ state insurance, income tax, customs and others) are deposited regularly, and any outstanding more than six months at year end | Unpaid tax and employee dues usually come before unpaid suppliers |
| 3(vii)(b) | Dues not deposited because of a dispute, with amounts and the forum | Contingent exposure; “a mere representation” to a department does not count as a dispute |
| 3(xi) | Any fraud “by the company or any fraud on the company” noticed or reported, with nature and amount; whether the auditor filed a fraud report on Form ADT-4; whether whistle-blower complaints were considered | The direct fraud signal |
| 3(xvii) | Whether the company “has incurred cash losses in the financial year and in the immediately preceding financial year”, with the amounts | Burning cash two years running |
| 3(xix) | Whether, on ratios, ageing, management plans and other information, the auditor believes “no material uncertainty exists” that the company can meet liabilities falling due within one year of the balance sheet date | CARO’s own short-term solvency question |
| 3(xviii) | Whether a statutory auditor resigned during the year, and whether the auditor considered “the issues, objections or concerns raised by the outgoing auditors” | Points you to an ADT-3 |
| 3(iii) | Loans, advances, guarantees and investments the company made: amounts to group and other parties, whether terms are prejudicial, overdue more than 90 days, loans renewed or replaced to settle overdues (3(iii)(e)), and loans repayable on demand or without terms, including to promoters and related parties (3(iii)(f)) | Money leaving the company on soft terms |
| 3(ii)(b) | Where working capital limits above ₹5 crore are secured on current assets, whether the quarterly returns filed with banks agree with the books | Stock and debtor statements given to banks that do not match the accounts |
| 3(i)(c) | Whether title deeds of immovable property are held in the company’s name, with details where they are not | Assets on the balance sheet the company may not own |
| 3(xxi) | In consolidated accounts only: qualifications or adverse remarks in the CARO reports of companies in the group, with names and paragraph numbers | Trouble sitting in a subsidiary |
How to read an answer
Most answers are “no” or “not applicable”, and that is the point. A healthy company’s CARO annexure reads as a run of negatives. You are reading for the exception.
An unfavourable answer must come with its basis. Paragraph 4(1): where an answer “is unfavourable or qualified, the auditor’s report shall also state the basis for such unfavourable or qualified answer”. Paragraph 4(2): where the auditor cannot express an opinion on a matter, the report must say so “together with the reasons”. So a bare “yes, there were defaults” is not allowed; the table and the reason follow.
Cash losses are not the same as a loss. The term is not defined in the Act or the accounting standards. ICAI’s guidance note suggests starting from profit or loss after tax and adjusting for non-cash items such as depreciation, amortisation and impairment. A company can report a loss and no cash loss, if the loss is mostly depreciation. A cash loss in both years is a stronger signal than an accounting loss.
Clause 3(xix) is worded defensively. Wipro’s auditor, in the example below, adds that the answer “is not an assurance as to the future viability of the Company”. A clean 3(xix) is not a guarantee; an unfavourable one is a serious statement.
CARO is not the opinion. A CARO answer can be unfavourable while the opinion on the accounts stays clean, because CARO asks about conduct and compliance, not only about the figures. Read both. For how the main opinion works, see modified audit opinions, emphasis of matter and key audit matters.
Where to find it
The CARO statement is an annexure to the independent auditor’s report. The report usually says, under “Report on Other Legal and Regulatory Requirements”, that “we give in ‘Annexure B’ a statement on the matters specified in paragraphs 3 and 4 of the Order”; the letter varies by firm.
The auditor’s report, with its annexures, is part of the financial statements the company files on AOC-4. For filings on the V3 portal of the Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA), the company also files a web-form extract of the auditor’s report. MCA’s instruction kit for the standalone extract shows it asks “Whether companies auditors report order (CARO) is applicable on company” and, if yes, records the auditor’s comment on each item as a favourable remark, an unfavourable remark, a disclaimer remark or “clause not applicable”, with details for the unfavourable and disclaimer ones.
In View Public Documents these extracts are listed as “EAUDITOR Standalone” and “EAUDITOR Consolidated” in the annual filings category. 1,456 standalone and 220 consolidated extract documents appeared in the company listings on Entiva as of 10 November 2026. You can see a company’s filings on its page on Entiva.
For a listed company, the annual report on its website or the stock exchange carries the same auditor’s report and annexure.
What to watch for
- An unfavourable 3(ix) or 3(vii) next to a clean opinion. It happens. The accounts can fairly show the default; CARO is where it is spelt out.
- Large amounts under 3(iii)(e) or (f). Loans renewed to settle overdues, or loans to promoters with no repayment terms, are the classic route for money to leave a company.
- Clause 3(xviii) answered “yes”. Find the ADT-3 and the ADT-1 for the new auditor, then read the outgoing auditor’s reasons.
- A 3(ii)(b) mismatch. Differences between the books and the quarterly stock statements given to banks are something a lender will ask about.
- A missing annexure where none should be missing. If the company is not exempt and the auditor’s report has no CARO statement, that is itself a question for the company.
- CARO 2016 and CARO 2020 number their clauses differently. Loan defaults were clause (viii) under CARO 2016 and are clause (ix) now, as ICAI’s clause-by-clause comparison shows. A note citing “clause 3(ix)” for a year before 2021-22 may mean a different question.
Worked example: Wipro’s CARO annexure for 2024-25
Wipro Limited’s Integrated Annual Report 2024-25 carries the standalone auditor’s report by Deloitte Haskins & Sells LLP, dated 22 May 2025, from page 174. Paragraph 2 of “Report on Other Legal and Regulatory Requirements” says that “we give in ‘Annexure B’ a statement on the matters specified in paragraphs 3 and 4 of the Order”. Annexure B runs from page 181 to page 185. Read the first-look clauses in order:
- 3(ix)(a) and (b): “the Company has not defaulted in the repayment of loans or other borrowings or in the payment of interest thereon to any lender during the year”, and “has not been declared wilful defaulter by any bank or financial institution or government or any government authority”.
- 3(vii)(a): undisputed statutory dues “have generally been regularly deposited”, with none in arrears for more than six months at 31 March 2025.
- 3(vii)(b): a table of dues not deposited “on account of disputes”, listing taxes, periods going back to the 1990s, and the forum for each. A company with clean answers elsewhere can still carry disputed dues; this is where you see their age and size.
- 3(xi): “no fraud by the Company and no material fraud on the Company has been noticed or reported during the year”, and no ADT-4 has been filed.
- 3(xvii): “The Company has not incurred cash losses during the financial year covered by our audit and the immediately preceding financial year.”
- 3(xviii): “There has been no resignation of the statutory auditors of the Company during the year.”
- 3(xix): “nothing has come to our attention, which causes us to believe that any material uncertainty exists”, followed by the standard line that this “is not an assurance as to the future viability of the Company”.
That is what a clean CARO annexure looks like: every clause above answered in the negative, the disputes table aside. Even so, read the rest. Wipro’s answer to 3(i)(c) names one exception: freehold land with a carrying amount of ₹404 million “for which the title deed has not been executed in the name of the Company pending with regulatory body for approval”. Against that baseline, a single “yes” in another company’s annexure stands out.
The detail, for practitioners
- Instrument. S.O. 849(E), 25 February 2020, published in the Gazette of India, Extraordinary, Part II, Section 3, Sub-section (ii); made under section 143(11) after consulting the National Financial Reporting Authority constituted under section 132; supersedes CARO 2016 (S.O. 1228(E), 29 March 2016) “except as respects things done or omitted to be done before such supersession”.
- Paragraph 2. Every report under section 143 on the accounts of a company to which the Order applies, for financial years commencing on or after 1 April 2019 as made, “shall in addition” contain the matters in paragraphs 3 and 4. S.O. 1219(E) of 24 March 2020 moved that date to 1 April 2020, and the Companies (Auditor’s Report) Second Amendment Order, 2020 (S.O. 4588(E), 17 December 2020) substituted “1st April, 2021” for “1st April, 2020”.
- The 21 clauses of paragraph 3:
- (i) property, plant and equipment and intangibles: records, physical verification, title deeds, revaluation (amount if the change is 10% or more per class), benami proceedings;
- (ii) inventory verification (discrepancies of 10% or more per class); working capital limits above ₹5 crore and agreement of quarterly returns;
- (iii) investments, guarantees, security and loans made, sub-clauses (a) to (f);
- (iv) compliance with sections 185 and 186;
- (v) deposits and deemed deposits under sections 73 to 76 and Reserve Bank of India directives, and any order of the Company Law Board, National Company Law Tribunal, Reserve Bank of India or a court;
- (vi) cost records under section 148(1);
- (vii) undisputed and disputed statutory dues;
- (viii) income surrendered or disclosed in tax assessments but not recorded in the books;
- (ix) defaults, wilful defaulter status, use of term loans, short-term funds used long-term, funds raised for subsidiaries, associates or joint ventures, and loans on the pledge of their securities, sub-clauses (a) to (f);
- (x) use of money raised by initial or further public offer, and compliance of preferential allotments and private placements with sections 42 and 62;
- (xi) fraud, ADT-4 reports under section 143(12) and rule 13 of the Companies (Audit and Auditors) Rules 2014, whistle-blower complaints;
- (xii) Nidhi companies: net owned funds to deposits of 1:20, 10% unencumbered term deposits, defaults on deposits;
- (xiii) related party transactions under sections 177 and 188;
- (xiv) internal audit system, and whether internal audit reports were considered;
- (xv) non-cash transactions with directors or connected persons, and section 192;
- (xvi) registration under section 45-IA of the Reserve Bank of India Act 1934, non-banking or housing finance activity without a certificate of registration, core investment company status, and the number of core investment companies in the group;
- (xvii) cash losses this year and last;
- (xviii) resignation of the statutory auditor;
- (xix) material uncertainty over meeting liabilities within one year;
- (xx) transfer of unspent corporate social responsibility (CSR) amounts to a Schedule VII fund within six months of year end, or to the special account under section 135(6) for ongoing projects;
- (xxi) qualifications or adverse remarks in group companies’ CARO reports (consolidated statements only).
- Paragraph 4. Reasons for unfavourable or qualified answers (4(1)) and for being unable to express an opinion (4(2)).
- Related reporting outside CARO. Section 143(3) lists the matters every auditor’s report covers, CARO or not, and rule 11 of the Audit and Auditors Rules adds more (pending litigation, foreseeable losses on long-term contracts, delays in transfers to the Investor Education and Protection Fund, and others added since). The modified audit opinion guide covers section 143(3).
- Exemption tests in 1(2)(v). All three conditions must hold, and the company must not be a holding or subsidiary of a public company. The borrowing test is “at any point of time during the financial year”, not at the balance sheet date; the revenue test uses revenue “as disclosed in Scheduled [sic] III to the Companies Act (including revenue from discontinuing operations)”.
- Small company. The exemption follows the definition in section 2(85) of the Act, so it moves whenever the small company thresholds are revised. Check the limits in force for the year audited.
Sources
- Companies (Auditor's Report) Order, 2020, S.O. 849(E), 25 February 2020: full text, Appendix I to ICAI's Guidance Note (Revised 2022 Edition), ICAI
- Companies (Auditor's Report) Order, 2020, Ministry of Corporate Affairs order of 25 February 2020 (copy published by IBBI), Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India
- Companies (Auditor's Report) Second Amendment Order, 2020, S.O. 4588(E), 17 December 2020, Gazette of India
- Companies Act 2013 (as amended), section 143, India Code
- Instruction kit for webform Extract of Auditor's Report (Standalone), Ministry of Corporate Affairs
- Instruction kit for webform Extract of Auditor's Report (Consolidated), Ministry of Corporate Affairs
- Wipro Limited, Integrated Annual Report 2024-25: standalone independent auditor's report and Annexure B, Wipro Limited