Key audit matters: what the auditor worried about most
Short answer
Key audit matters are the few areas that took the auditor's most significant attention this year, each with why it mattered and how it was audited. Listed companies' reports must include them, and they are neither qualifications nor a separate opinion on each area.
What a key audit matter is
When a mechanic services a car, the bill lists everything done. A good mechanic also tells you, separately, the two or three things that took real work this time: “the brakes were close to the limit, so we measured them twice”. The car still passed. But now you know where the effort, and the risk, sat.
Key audit matters (KAMs) are the auditor’s version of that: the few areas of this year’s audit that took the most significant attention, set out in a section of their own. They are defined in the Standard on Auditing (SA) 701, issued by the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI), as “those matters that, in the auditor’s professional judgment, were of most significance in the audit of the financial statements of the current period” (SA 701, paragraph 8).
They appear in a section of the auditor’s report headed “Key Audit Matters”. Each one has a subheading, a reference to the related note in the accounts, and two parts: why the auditor thought it was one of the most significant matters, and how it was addressed in the audit (paragraphs 11 and 13). The report in the worked example below sets these out as a two-column table.
SA 701 gives the purpose plainly: to “enhance the communicative value of the auditor’s report by providing greater transparency about the audit that was performed” (paragraph 2).
Which companies must report them
The rule is in SA 700 (Revised), paragraph 30: “For audits of complete sets of general purpose financial statements of listed entities, the auditor shall communicate key audit matters in the auditor’s report in accordance with SA 701.”
For everyone else, key audit matters appear only when:
- law or regulation requires them (SA 700, paragraph 31); or
- the auditor decides to include them (paragraph 31). SA 700’s application material gives examples of entities where an auditor might, such as financial institutions like banks, insurance companies and pension funds, and charities (paragraph A36).
So the answer to “are key audit matters mandatory for unlisted companies?” is: not under the auditing standards, unless a law or regulation requires them. An unlisted company’s report may have no such section, and its absence there tells you nothing.
One exception runs the other way. If the auditor disclaims an opinion, the report must not include key audit matters, unless law or regulation requires them (SA 705 (Revised), paragraph 29).
How the auditor chooses them
The selection is a funnel (SA 701, paragraphs 9 and 10):
- Start with everything the auditor discussed with those charged with governance, the board or audit committee.
- Narrow to the matters that required significant auditor attention, taking into account areas of higher assessed risk or significant risks, areas of significant management judgement (including estimates with high estimation uncertainty), and significant events or transactions in the year.
- From those, pick the matters of most significance. These are the key audit matters.
A listed company’s report will usually have at least one: SA 701 says it may be rare for an auditor of a listed entity not to determine any, though it can happen, for example, for a listed entity with very limited operations (paragraph A59). When there are none, the report still has the heading and says so (paragraph 16).
Each one maps where the accounts lean on judgement
Read the “why” column as a map of the hard parts. SA 701 points the auditor at higher-risk areas, significant management judgements and estimates, and significant events in the year. So key audit matters tell you where the accounts lean most on judgement; in the example below, the value of investments in loss-making subsidiaries and exposure to tax and legal disputes.
Read the “how” column for what was actually tested. Did the auditor involve specialists, test controls, read legal opinions, recompute a model? It tells you how much assurance sits behind a judgemental number, though not what the auditor concluded about it in isolation.
Follow the note reference. Each key audit matter points to a note. The note has the amounts and the company’s own assumptions.
Compare years. Key audit matters are chosen for the current period, so the list can change. Ask why a new matter appeared and why an old one dropped out.
Compare with peers. A key audit matter that one company has and its peers do not is a question worth asking the company.
What a key audit matter is not
SA 701 (paragraph 4) lists what communicating key audit matters is not:
- Not a qualification. It is not “a substitute for the auditor expressing a modified opinion”. An auditor must not put a matter in this section when it requires a modified opinion (paragraph 12). A long list of key audit matters in a report with a clean opinion is still a clean opinion. For opinions that are modified, see qualified, adverse and disclaimer of opinion.
- Not a separate opinion on each matter. The section must say that the matters “were addressed in the context of the audit of the financial statements as a whole” and that the auditor “does not provide a separate opinion on these matters” (paragraph 11).
- Not a substitute for the company’s own disclosures. The facts belong in the notes; the key audit matter only refers to them.
- Not the going concern warning. A material uncertainty related to going concern is reported in its own section under SA 570 (Revised), not as a key audit matter.
The most important matter may sit outside the table
A qualification and a going concern uncertainty are, in SA 701’s words, “by their nature key audit matters”, but they are not described in this section. They go in their own sections, and the Key Audit Matters section refers to them (paragraph 15). That is why many reports open the section with “In addition to the matter described in the Basis for Qualified Opinion section” or “In addition to the matter described in the Material Uncertainty Related to Going Concern section”. When you see that sentence, go back up the report: the most important matter is not in the table.
An emphasis of matter paragraph is never used for a matter that is already a key audit matter (SA 706 (Revised), paragraph 8(b)). If the auditor wants to stress a key audit matter, SA 706 suggests presenting it first or adding to its description (paragraph A2). See emphasis of matter.
The auditor’s report is filed with the financial statements on AOC-4, and a group’s consolidated accounts carry their own report with their own key audit matters. You can see a company’s filings on Entiva. The auditor’s checklist annexure under the Companies (Auditor’s Report) Order, 2020 is separate again: see CARO 2020. If the auditor later resigns, the notice is filed on ADT-3.
Worked example: JSW Steel’s key audit matters, 2024-25
JSW Steel Limited is listed, so its standalone auditor’s report for the year ended 31 March 2025, by S R B C & CO LLP, has a Key Audit Matters section (JSW Steel Integrated Report 2024-25, standalone financial statements, page 422 onwards). It opens with the standard wording, then: “In addition to the matter described in the ‘Basis for Qualified Opinion’ section we have determined the matters described below to be the key audit matters”. The report’s opinion is qualified, and the qualified matter is kept out of the table, exactly as SA 701 paragraph 15 requires.
The matters in the table include:
- Recoverability of investments in, and loans and guarantees for, certain subsidiaries (note 48). The report states investments of ₹1,044 crore and loans or guarantees of ₹17,501 crore relating to subsidiaries that have either been incurring losses or whose investments in step-down subsidiaries have been making losses, and an impairment allowance of ₹3,762 crore recognised in the year on investments in and loans to certain overseas subsidiaries. The “how” column lists testing the impairment model’s discount rates and growth rates, comparing cash flow forecasts with past performance, and sensitivity analysis.
- Accuracy and completeness of related party disclosures (note 44), given the significance of related party transactions in the year and the requirements of the Companies Act 2013 and the listing regulations of the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI).
- Claims and exposures relating to taxation and litigation (note 45). The report cites contingent liabilities of ₹3,149 crore for disputed tax and legal matters and ₹5,333 crore for claims related to forest development tax or fee, and records that the auditor involved tax specialists and read external legal opinions where needed.
How a reader would use this: the subsidiary matter tells you that the recoverable value of these investments and loans rests on management’s forecasts, and that an impairment of ₹3,762 crore was recognised in the year; the auditor notes that changes in the assumptions could lead to further impairment or to reversals. Note 48 has the detail. The litigation matter tells you where the contingent liabilities are disclosed and how large they are. None of these is a qualification. The one matter the auditor said it was unable to assess is the one in the Basis for Qualified Opinion section, above the table. All of this is as stated in the report signed on 23 May 2025.
For contrast, Vodafone Idea Limited’s standalone report for the same year (Annual Report 2024-25, page 145) says in its Key Audit Matters section, after the standard wording, “In addition to the matter described in the ‘Material Uncertainty Related to Going Concern’ section”. There, too, the most important matter sits outside the table.
The detail, for practitioners
Standard and date. SA 701, issued in May 2016, effective for audits of financial statements for periods beginning on or after 1 April 2018 (paragraph 6).
Scope (paragraph 5). Applies to audits of complete sets of general purpose financial statements of listed entities, to circumstances where the auditor otherwise decides to communicate key audit matters, and where law or regulation requires it. SA 705 (Revised), paragraph 29, prohibits key audit matters on a disclaimer unless law or regulation requires them. SA 700 (Revised) paragraphs 30 and 31 carry the same applicability; A35 notes that law may require key audit matters for entities characterised as public interest entities, and A36 gives examples where the auditor may decide to.
Determination (paragraphs 9 and 10). From matters communicated with those charged with governance, those that required significant auditor attention, considering: (a) areas of higher assessed risk of material misstatement or significant risks identified under SA 315; (b) significant auditor judgements on areas of significant management judgement, including estimates with high estimation uncertainty; (c) the effect on the audit of significant events or transactions. Then those of most significance.
Communication (paragraphs 11 to 16). Separate section headed “Key Audit Matters”, with prescribed introductory language. Each description refers to the related disclosure and addresses why the matter was a key audit matter and how it was addressed. Matters requiring a modified opinion are excluded (paragraph 12). A matter is not described where law or regulation precludes public disclosure, or, in extremely rare cases, where the adverse consequences would reasonably be expected to outweigh the public interest benefit; the latter does not apply if the entity has publicly disclosed the matter (paragraph 14). Modified-opinion and going concern matters are reported under their own SAs and cross-referred (paragraph 15). Where there are none, or only paragraph 15 matters, a statement to that effect under the heading (paragraph 16).
Governance and documentation (paragraphs 17 and 18). The auditor communicates the key audit matters, or the determination that there are none, to those charged with governance, and documents the rationale for each determination.
Adverse opinions (A7). With an adverse opinion, the auditor may determine that no other matters are key audit matters; where others are described, they must not imply the statements are more credible on those matters than the adverse opinion allows.
Sources
- SA 701: Communicating Key Audit Matters in the Independent Auditor's Report, ICAI
- SA 700 (Revised): Forming an Opinion and Reporting on Financial Statements, ICAI
- SA 705 (Revised): Modifications to the Opinion in the Independent Auditor's Report, ICAI
- SA 706 (Revised): Emphasis of Matter Paragraphs and Other Matter Paragraphs in the Independent Auditor's Report, ICAI
- JSW Steel Limited, Integrated Report 2024-25: standalone financial statements and independent auditor's report, JSW Steel Limited
- Vodafone Idea Limited, Annual Report 2024-25: independent auditor's reports, Vodafone Idea Limited